The shoes do look nice in person, but looking nice and fitting properly are not the same thing. Unfortunately, my overall experience with BLKBRD Shoemaker was disappointing.
I selected brass toe taps only, but my shoes arrived with rubber patches added to the soles. When I raised this, they explained the benefits of rubber patches. I understand those benefits. If I wanted rubber patches, I would have selected and paid for that option. Presenting an unrequested change as a benefit does not address why my chosen specification was not followed.
The fit was far too loose despite providing my foot measurements before ordering. My feet moved inside the shoes and felt like they could slip out. I tried the extra insoles they supplied, which improved the fit around the middle slightly, but the excess length and space at the heel remained.
Their further advice was to wear thick socks and let the leather mold to my feet. Being told to wear thick socks to compensate for oversized dress shoes was particularly frustrating. Leather softening and conforming to the feet can help when shoes are initially snug, but these were already too loose. Breaking them in will not make them shrink to fit or resolve the excess length and heel space.
They also offered a 10% discount on a future order, which does nothing to resolve the problems with the pair I already purchased.
For me, after-sales service is what demonstrates a company’s professionalism, and this response fell well short. I expected them to take responsibility and arrange a replacement pair that matched my order and fit properly. Instead, their response left me feeling that the priority was to close the complaint quickly rather than resolve it.
Good leather and attractive shoes are only part of the experience, especially when buying something that is supposed to feel premium. The service should build trust and a lasting relationship with the customer. After paying for the shoes and shipping, I expected better. As things stand, this will most likely be my only purchase from BLKBRD.